THE EFFECT OF MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS ON THE PERFORMANCE OF THE NIGERIAN BANKING INDUSTRY
This study examined the effect of mergers and acquisitions on the performance of Nigerian banking industry. In order to strengthen the competitive and operational capabilities of banks in Nigeria with a view towards returning global and public confidence to the Nigerian banking sector and the economy in general, the Central Bank of Nigeria instituted a banking reform in 2004, which saw most of the then existing 89 banks merging with each other. The fundamental objectives of this research is to ascertain the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the liquidity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria, examine how mergers and acquisitions adopted by commercial banks impacted on the return on equity of the affected banks, evaluate the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the debt/equity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria and examine the extent to which earning per share of commercial banks improved as a result of mergers and acquisitions. An ex post facto research design was adopted in this study. The population of the study comprises of all 21 commercial banks in Nigeria. The study covered a period of 15years from 1998 to 2012. Secondary sources of data were used in this study. The data were handpicked from the annual reports of the sampled banks and internet. The data obtained were analyzed using panel data analysis. The method of estimation used is the Ordinary Least Square (OLS). The result of the study indicated that overall mergers and acquisitions has a positive effect on the liquidity profile, return on equity, debt/equity profile and earning per share of commercial banks. The study recommends that the monetary authorities should establish an institutional framework to sustain the positive and improved performance of the banking industry in response to mergers and acquisitions.
TABLE OF CONTENT
Title Page i
Approval Page iii
Table of content vii
List of tables and figures x
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study1
Statement of the Problem2
Objectives of the Study3
Scope of the Study4
Significance of the Study4
Operational definition of terms5
CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
Merger and Acquisition9
Reasons for mergers and acquisition10
Consequences of mergers and acquisition12
Brand implication of M&A on banks12
Structural implications of M&A on banks15
M & A research paradigms16
Economic and finance perspective17
Organisational behaviour perspective17
Human resource management perspective18
Stages of M & A19
Corporate strategy development19
Organising for acquisition20
Deal structuring and negotiation20
Post acquisition integration21
Post acquisition and organisational learning22
Nigerian banking sector regulatory agencies22
Federal ministry of finance23
Central bank of Nigeria23
Nigerian deposit insurance corporation24
Securities and exchange commission24
Trends in Bank consolidation24
Mergers and acquisition waves27
An overview of the Nigerian bank consolidation exercise28
Strategies for consolidation adopted by Nigerian banks29
Elements of the banking reform36
Legal Hurdles for M& A38
Traditional views of the value of M&A38
Critical success issues of M&A40
Challenges of the banking reforms43
Prospect and effect of banking consolidation45
Some prior study51
CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Nature and Sources of Data68
Population and Sample Size69
Description of Research Variables71
Return on Equity72
184.108.40.206 Earning Per Share 73
Techniques of Data Analysis73
CHAPTER FOUR PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS OF DATA
Presentation of Data76
Computation of the Ratio Values76
Test of Hypothesis78
Test of Hypothesis One78
Test of Hypothesis Two80
Test of Hypothesis Three81
Test of Hypothesis Four83
Granger Causality Test85
Implication of the result86
CHAPTER FIVE SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary of Findings95
Conclusion of the Study95
Recommendations of the Study95
Recommendation for Further Studies97
Contribution to Knowledge97
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES
Table 4.1 Values of Model Proxies 99
Table 4.2 Computed Ratio Values of the Model Proxies 104
Table 4.3 Augmented Dicker fuller unit root test (after detrending and differencing) 77
Table 4.4 Shows the new data set after differencing and detrending 113
Table 4.4.1 Ordinary Least Square result of hypothesis one 79
Table 4.4.2 Ordinary Least Square result of hypothesis two 80
Table 4.4.3 Ordinary Least Square result of hypothesis three 82
Table 4.4.4 Ordinary Least Square result of hypothesis four 83
Table 4.5 Granger causality test 84
Table 2.2List of Banks in Nigeria as at January 1, 2006
Table 2.3 Basic indicators of banking sector consolidation results pre-consolidation 34
Table 2.4 Distressed banks and the new banks that acquired those 34
Table 2.5 List of existing banks in Nigeria 35
Table 2.1 Summary of major mergers and acquisition waves in the US 28
Figure 1 Line graphs showing the stationarity of panel data series: SHE 108
Figure 2 Line graphs showing the stationarity of panel data series: liquidity ratio 109
Figure 3 Line graphs showing the stationarity of panel data series: return on equity 110
Figure 4 Line graphs showing the stationarity of panel data series: debt/equity ratio 111 Figure 5 Line graphs showing the stationarity of panel data series: earning per share112
Background of the Study
The Nigerian banking sector has undergone remarkable changes over the years, in terms of the number of institutions, ownership structure, as well as the depth of operations. These changes have been influenced largely by challenges posed by deregulation of the financial sector, globalization of operations, technological innovations and adoption of supervisory and prudential requirements that conform to international standards.
The Nigerian banking industry witnessed dramatic transformation during the recapitalization exercise which deadline was December 31st, 2005. Overall, the banking sector experience steady consolidation through recapitalization and mergers and acquisitions that have resulted in fewer banks holding a greater value of the total assets in the sector (Okpanachi, 2011). Spearheaded by the announcement of the Central Bank of Nigeria on July 6, 2004 about a major reform program that would transform the banking landscape of the country, an unprecedented process of merger and acquisition took place in the Nigerian banking sector, shrinking the number of banks.
Immediately after the recapitalization deadline ended on December 31st, 2005, the number of operating banks in the country reduced from 89 banks to 25banks but later reduced further to 23 with the merger of some banks like First Atlantic Bank Plc and Inland Bank to form Fin Bank Plc. Stanbic Bank Plc and IBTC to form Stanbic-IBTC Bank. The number of operating bank later increased to 24 banks with the entry of Citibank Nigeria Limited. The merger and acquisition of the nine rescued banks i.e. the merger of Access Bank Plc with Intercontinental Bank Plc: Merger of Ecobank Transnational Incorporation with Oceanic Bank Plc: merger of First City Monumental Bank with Fin Bank Plc further reduced the number of banks operating in Nigeria to 21.
The wave of mergers and acquisitions that had taken place in the Nigerian banking industry raises an important question of whether bank consolidation enhances the financial performance of Nigeria banks. Hosono et al (2007) argued that consolidation may increase or decrease the performance of a bank. Mergers and Acquisitions are common place in developing countries of the world but are just becoming prominent in Nigeria especially in the banking industry. Umoren (2007) says that merger and acquisition is simply another way
of saying survival of the fittest that is to say a bigger, more efficient, better-capitalized, more skilled industry.
As the banks are devising ways of improving efficiency and ensuring the optimization of the available resources, policy makers and regulatory authorities are moving towards openness, competiveness, and at the same time ensuring market discipline. This is in tandem with the trend in the banking sector globally. Ahmed (2000:33) described this development as a magic one which caused quite a substantial number of Nigerian banks to be sick while some became healthier. In his view, he contended that growth in the banking sector should be transmitted easily into growth of the real sector. But as banks continued to record impressive growth in all economics, indices show a declining margin of economic growth. This makes one wonder where the impacts of the impressive performance of the banks as reported in the financial reports are being felt. Even the NDIC (Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation) which is established to insure the deposit liabilities of licensed banks has liquidated some distressed banks. The action, Ezeikpe (1993: 36-38) commended while arguing that some distressed banks should be liquidated as a way of survival for the banking system.
This study seeks to evaluate the effect of mergers and acquisitions as strategic growth option in the Nigerian banking sector, with a view to find out if mergers and acquisitions result in superior financial performance, efficient, reliable and sound capital base for the bank that fully embraced it.
Statement of the Problem
The outbreak of bank mergers in Nigeria is attracting much attention, partly because of heightened interest in what motivates firms to merger and how mergers affect efficiency. However, there are often two distinct views to the rationale behind merger and acquisition. The first held view of mergers, especially those involving mega firms, is that firms are merging just to get bigger and not to get more efficient. Accompanying that notion is the fear that as merging firms grab greater market share, individual freedoms, competition and efficiency are threatened, because bigger is perceived as greater concentration of power.
The second view holds that firm’s merger not just to get bigger but also to be more efficient. It is claimed that mergers enable the banking industry to take advantage of new opportunities created by changes in the technological and regulatory environment. Fallout of this is the reduction in the number of banks nationwide but the concentration of power in local banking markets has not increased. And the very force of regulatory change that spurred bank merger
is also bringing new sources of competition of local banking market (especially the management of the country’s external reserves). The post-consolidation performance of all Nigerian banks was overcast in 2009 by the global financial and economic crisis, which was precipitated in August 2007 by the collapse of the sub-prime lending market in the United States. Sanusi (2010) attributed the post consolidation challenges of Nigerian banking industry to the inability of the industry and the regulators to sustain and monitor the sector’s explosive growth which as a result led to risk-build in the system. This study shall investigate the effect of the merger and acquisition that had taken place in the Nigerian banking sector on the performance of the selected banks 1998-2012.
Objectives of the Study
In a broad framework, the general objective of the study is to examine the effect of mergers and acquisitions on the performance of the Nigerian banking sector
The specific objectives of this study were to:
1. ascertain the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the liquidity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria.
2. examine how mergers and acquisitions adopted by commercial banks impacted on the return on equity of the affected banks.
3. evaluate the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the debt/equity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria.
4. examine the extent to which earning per share of commercial banks improved as a result of mergers and acquisitions.
The following research questions are considered relevant for the purpose of this research work:
1. What effect does mergers and acquisitions have on the liquidity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria?
2. Do mergers and acquisitions have any effect on return on equity of commercial banks in Nigeria?
3. What effect does mergers and acquisitions have on the debt equity profile of the commercial banks in Nigeria?
4. To what extent have mergers and acquisitions adopted by banks impacted on the earning per share of the affected banks?
For the purpose of this research, the following hypothetical statements stated in their null forms are considered relevant in order to guide the researcher properly:
H1: Mergers and acquisitions do not have any significant positive effect on the liquidity profile of the affected banks.
H2: Mergers and acquisitions have no significant positive effect on the return on equity of commercial banks.
H3: Mergers and acquisitions do not have any significant positive effect on the debt equity profile of commercial banks in Nigeria
H4: Mergers and acquisitions have no significant positive impact on the earning per share of the affected banks.
Scope of the Study
This research focus on the effect of mergers and acquisitions on the performance of the Nigerian banking industry.The time frame for the analysis is 1998 – 2012, a period of fifteen
(15) years. This is with the understanding that the time frame will only be fair and balance for analyzing their performance. It is also extended to 2012 to ensure that the information and data used are timely, up to date and accurate enough to represent the current position of the banks under study.
Significance of Study
The major significance of this study relates to the evaluation of mergers and acquisitions in terms of its impact on the performance in the post-consolidation era in the Nigerian banking sector, this will serve as a yardstick for the justification of the exercise. This study will also add to the general body of knowledge on the subject matter of mergers and acquisitions and also compliment the work of other authors.
In furtherance to the above, this research will also be significant to:
The policy makers and regulators of the banking industry, it will present a schema, through its analysis that could assist them in evolving policies and reforms that will positively impact on the performance of the banking industry.
To the public, it will enlighten the general public on the effect of bank consolidation on the performance of banks in Nigeria, and also provide a better understanding of the dynamics of the Nigerian banking industry and how it has performed within the period under review.
To investors in general, the study exposes the relationship existing between relevant variable used in this study. Investors will be in a better position to make rational investment decisions as the study will make them understand better the nature of relationship existing between mergers and acquisitions and various performance index of the Nigerian banking industry.
To students, the research will assist those who wish to take a career in economics, banking and finance to advance their understanding of the concept and mechanism of mergers and acquisitions and its effects.
Finally, the research work will serve as a reference material for future researchers on similar topic.
Operational Definition of Terms
Merger: In business or economics a merger is a combination of two companies into one larger company. Such actions are commonly voluntary and involve stock swap or cash payment to the target. Stock swap is often used as it allows the shareholders of the two companies to share the risks involved in the deal.
Acquisition: This means the buying of one company (the target) by another. An acquisition may be friendly or hostile. In the former case, the companies cooperate in negotiations; in the latter case, the takeover target is unwilling to be bought or the targets board has no prior knowledge of the offer. Acquisition usually refers to a purchase of a smaller firm by a larger one.
Bank Re-Capitalization: It is the act of supplying long-term funds of the owners of the bank to meet the requirement of monetary authority. Osiegbu (2005).
Consolidation: It is the reduction in the number of banks and other deposit taking institution with a simultaneous increase in the size and concentration of the consolidation entities in the sector (BIS, 2001:2)
Shareholder’s fund: are alternative terms for owners’ or shareholders equity. It represents the funds invested in the company through stock purchase or other private investments.
Economy: The relationship between production, trade and the supply of money in a particular country or region. It is the system of trade and industry by which the wealth of a country is made and used.
Ajayi, M. (2005).Banking sector reforms and bank consolidation: conceptual framework. In: Banking sector reforms and bank consolidation in Nigeria.CBN bullion, Vol.
29, No. 3. April/June.
Ahmed, M. (1989).Mergers and Acquisition as Alternative Growth Strategy to Nigerian Firms under SAP.Nigeria Institute of Management Seminar, Lagos.
Anaeto, Emeka. (1998, November 23). Counting the Gains of Corporate Restructuring.
Business Times, P. 41.
Ansoff, H. Igor et al (1976).“From Strategic Planning to Strategic Management” Hiley, New York.
Berger,A.N et al (1999). Journal of Banking & Finance, Vol. 23 pp. 135-194. Elsevier, Netherlands
Barney J. (1986). “Strategic Factor Markets; Expectations, Luck and Business Strategy”
Management Science, Vol. 42, pp 1231-1241.
Ebeid F. J. (1976). “Tender Offers; Characteristics Affecting their success” Mergers and Acquisitions.
Ezikpe, J. N. (1993). Corporate Responsiveness to Structural Changes: Lectures and Proceedings of Bank Directors Seminar. Lagos: Financial Institution Training Centre,
pp. 36 – 58.
Gaughan,P.A(1999). Mergers, Acquisitions and Corporate Restructuring, second edition, John Wiley and Sons,. New York
Gaughan,P.A (1999). Mergers, Acquisitions and Corporate Restructuring, second edition, John Wiley and Sons,. New York
Glueck William (1980). “Business Policy and Strategic Management” Mcgraw Hill Goorey,G (1999). “Merger disruption”, in Global Finance ,New York.
Hanweck ,G.A and Shull,B (1999). “The bank merger movement: Efficiency, stability and competitive policy concerns”, in Antitrust Bulletin, New York.
Hosono, K; Sakai, K. and Tsuru, K. (2007).‘Consolidation of Banks in Japan; Causes and Consequences’. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Working
Paper Series, No. 13399
Okpanachi.J. (2011).‘Comparative analysis of the impact of mergers and acquisitions on financial efficiency of banks in Nigeria’.Journal of Accounting and Taxation,
Vol. 3, No. 1, pp.1-7
Osiegbu (2005).“The efficiency effects of bank mergers: An overview of case studies of nine mergers”, Journal of Banking and Finance, No. 22 (1998), pp. 273-291
Umoren (2007).“Asset redeployment, acquisition and corporate strategies in declining industries” strategic management journal. Vol., 23 pp. 119-134..